Jigen, Sexuality, & Subtext

Well just as much as you're allowed to interpret Jigen however you'd like, if official authors release is what matters to you, after Zero, the fact that Lupin and Jigen have feelings for each other is 100% canonical rather than just subtext. But aside from that, unless you have the ability to truly glimpse into the mind of everyone who worked on the show for the past 50 years I don't think you can really say what they each thought about Jigen's sexuality definitively. Of course many of them thought of him as straight, but that's not what we're talking about here.

Something to be clear on is that words and their translation is always complicated, especially when a word can mean VERY different things to different subcultures. Queer people tend to have words that, especially historically, have secret meanings, or imply different things to the in group than to the out group. There was no one saying that onnagirai is not a word that means misogyny, it's that words can mean different things culturally in different contexts. The twitter thread even referred specifically to kabuki as the context.

For examples in English, there are words like "avowed bachelor" which means being a single man, but in certain circumstances and contexts like in movies, was a way to say a gay man. Because being gay was and still is criminalized and stigmatized, innuendo is necessary to discuss the topic without being censored.

I am not a native Japanese speaker so I can't speak definitively on it but the twitter thread did share some essay references about queerness in kabuki. I think it's important to say that a non-Queer Japanese speaker might not know all the alternative meanings to words as they are intended to be coded language for "forbidden" behaviors. This kind of meaning-making takes place in trusted communities, rather than being on the surface. This is one of the most interesting things about language in my opinion, that words don't just have a single meaning, they have a contextual meaning that can shift over time.

Another English example since that's my native language is the word "epic" in just the span of my lifetime this word went from referring mainly to a type of grand story, to a really positive internet slang meaning "very cool" to falling out of favor and now despite still meaning "very cool" people who use the word are considered dorky or out of touch with current slang. Words are never so easy as to be seen in a narrow singular way for decades.
As I said it’s not my intention of telling people what to think or feel in their own personal interpretation, I’m just curious about the singling out the sexuality of one specific character that, officially, was never intended as gay. It’s not me saying that: it’s the official press releases, press releases that go back since the pilot, part 1, part 2 and into the movies. It’s the role of the romantic lead the authors gave and keep giving to the character, role that has always be a constant.

By the tone of the original manga I wouldn’t think MP would have shied away if he wanted a character to be gay: in one story Lupin has sex with MP himself! It’s for laughs, ok, but one would think there would be no reason for the author to avoid to talk about a character’s sexuality.

That Lupin and Jigen are friends since childhood is not me and neither Lupin Zero stating that, it’s a fact from as early as chapter 11 of the original manga. Monkey Punch made them very close friends who care deeply for each other and yes we can say that they love each other but that doesn’t necessarily has to do with them or one of them being gay. We have Lupin who’s a sex maniac and Jigen who’s more the romantic type and has a girlfriend. I for example am perfectly fine with the way they have always treated the Lupin and Jigen relationship with the same importance they usually reserve for romantic love stories. Jigen is not less important than Fujiko, if you get my meaning. That’s already original in itself.

As regarding terminology again “onnagirai” is not slang for “gay”, Japanese words have precise meaning and in no way the words onna 女 and girai 嫌い have to do with homosexuality.

What people seem to not take into consideration with this franchise is that it is supposed to be fun, instead I see people getting seriously invested in thematics that are just not there. So it’s just simple curiosity on my part. For example in one episode Goemon is singing YMCA by the Village People… no one seem to take that into consideration. Why? Because it’s perceived, rightly so, as a joke? So why is Jigen instead perceived as gay in a serious way? If I have to be honest I have a bit of a concern that some people might be too invested and end up delusional.
 

Tsushi

Matcha-Coated Tanuki Mod
Admin
Pronouns
He/They
That Lupin and Jigen are friends since childhood is not me and neither Lupin Zero stating that, it’s a fact from as early as chapter 11 of the original manga. Monkey Punch made them very close friends who care deeply for each other and yes we can say that they love each other but that doesn’t necessarily has to do with them or one of them being gay.
I think it's deliberately obtuse to see two characters blushingly saying one stole the other one's heart without assuming that's love.
As regarding terminology again “onnagirai” is not slang for “gay”, Japanese words have precise meaning and in no way the words onna 女 and girai 嫌い have to do with homosexuality.
You are ignoring what I am saying that words mean much more than just the literal definition. All languages have nuances to what their words mean in context. What scholarship do you have that would indicate this word has never had to do with homosexuality?
What people seem to not take into consideration with this franchise is that it is supposed to be fun, instead I see people getting seriously invested in thematics that are just not there. So it’s just simple curiosity on my part. For example in one episode Goemon is singing YMCA by the Village People… no one seem to take that into consideration. Why? Because it’s perceived, rightly so, as a joke? So why is Jigen instead perceived as gay in a serious way? If I have to be honest I have a bit of a concern that some people might be too invested and end up delusional.
I think this is ignoring the fact that for gay fans, it IS fun to see ourselves in characters we love. And it is fun to dig deeper, even if this is just theory. I don't really feel that you came here to engage in this discussion in good faith. You seem to have come into the one thread about Jigen being gay and call people delusional. This is despite the fact that in the literal actual TV show they have made Lupin and Jigen bi. It's on screen, it's text, not subtext. Even if Monkey Punch didn't write it, most of the show is not written by him.

If you want to talk about Fujiko and Jigen's relationship or something like that, that's very welcome and encouraged. This is a space to enjoy Lupin the Third, and I think they have a very interesting relationship personally, even if I don't see them as in love. I still think that's a very valid avenue to explore. Just not on this thread.

No one is forcing you personally to change your own interpretations. But you have no more special insight into the mind of the creative team behind the show than any of us.

I do feel suspicious that you didn't even introduce yourself or have any other discussion in the forum, you instead came to a thread about gay subtext to call queer people delusional. Consider this a firm warning about your behavior. You are welcome to talk about your own interpretations, but not to insult other people who interpret the work differently than you.
 
Well, I’m sorry you feel this way as it wasn’t my intention of insulting anyone. On the contrary you’re calling me obtuse… and think I need to be lectured about queer culture and nuances in languages.

I said more than once that I was trying to understand the apparent fixation with a specific character that has being constantly portrayed as straight. Personal interpretations are different from the actual characters? Ok, perfectly fine with me.

As for Lupin and Jigen, where did I say it was not love? Love has many different meanings, two friends can love each other without that having sexual connotations.

I really think it’s a cultural thing that most American people don’t get. Friendship is highly valued by Japanese people, so two friends who love each other is probably not a thing that translates well in other parts of the world.

No, I don’t want to talk about Jigen and Fujiko, again it’s the authors who put that in the character profile.

It all comes down to shipping in the end, right? It’s got nothing to do with queer representation but with shipping this character with that character.

We could have had a normal exchange of views but I see it’s not the case here.
 
Last edited:
Pronouns
She/her
As someone who is queer herself it actually makes me very happy that one of my favourite characters ever has at least some queer coding, in my head jigen is totally gay
 

Tsushi

Matcha-Coated Tanuki Mod
Admin
Pronouns
He/They
I think if Lupin and Jigen in Zero were a boy and a girl in that exact situation and setup, people wouldn't argue it was merely friendship. I think that's a stretch to call it anything other than romantic, that's why I am calling that obtuse.

This board is called "headcanons and shipping discussion" so what we're talking about here is that topic. There are a lot of posts in this thread that share the reasoning behind why people view Jigen this way. No one in this thread has said this is the only way to view him, only that we do view him this way and why. This is about personal interpretation, that's the subject of the board.

If what you're asking is out of only curiosity here is my feelings on queer Jigen:

For me there are plenty of episodes that hint at him liking women, but there are also many that suggest he likes men, especially Lupin. There are many moments where Lupin abandons him for a women where Jigen reacts in a way that is easy to read as jealousy, that would be called jealousy if Jigen was a woman. I think it's just bias that people have towards heteronormativity that makes them not see that jealousy as romantic.

I think there is ample evidence for both interpretations. To see him as defaultly being straight is only a presumption, and while it's valid to read his jealousy as being because he wants Lupin to be "loyal" to him as a friend, for me it's jealousy of a man who is in love, and who can't seem to capture Lupin's affection the way women can, and who finds that frustrating.

I think the easiest interpretation is of him being bisexual, because he does seem to have some history with women, though we never know for sure how deep those relationships were.

There is no evidence that refutes that, in my opinion. But that's just how I see the show. I see in almost all episodes Jigen has with women the way he flinches away from physical intimacy with women, despite wanting to show them care and love. He cares about them, but it just seems like he wants to protect them and that he's not sexually attracted them. He tends to be much more physical with men, Goemon and Lupin. That's how it reads to me, and that's why I see him as gay.
 
I think if Lupin and Jigen in Zero were a boy and a girl in that exact situation and setup, people wouldn't argue it was merely friendship. I think that's a stretch to call it anything other than romantic, that's why I am calling that obtuse.

This board is called "headcanons and shipping discussion" so what we're talking about here is that topic. There are a lot of posts in this thread that share the reasoning behind why people view Jigen this way. No one in this thread has said this is the only way to view him, only that we do view him this way and why. This is about personal interpretation, that's the subject of the board.

If what you're asking is out of only curiosity here is my feelings on queer Jigen:

For me there are plenty of episodes that hint at him liking women, but there are also many that suggest he likes men, especially Lupin. There are many moments where Lupin abandons him for a women where Jigen reacts in a way that is easy to read as jealousy, that would be called jealousy if Jigen was a woman. I think it's just bias that people have towards heteronormativity that makes them not see that jealousy as romantic.

I think there is ample evidence for both interpretations. To see him as defaultly being straight is only a presumption, and while it's valid to read his jealousy as being because he wants Lupin to be "loyal" to him as a friend, for me it's jealousy of a man who is in love, and who can't seem to capture Lupin's affection the way women can, and who finds that frustrating.

I think the easiest interpretation is of him being bisexual, because he does seem to have some history with women, though we never know for sure how deep those relationships were.

There is no evidence that refutes that, in my opinion. But that's just how I see the show. I see in almost all episodes Jigen has with women the way he flinches away from physical intimacy with women, despite wanting to show them care and love. He cares about them, but it just seems like he wants to protect them and that he's not sexually attracted them. He tends to be much more physical with men, Goemon and Lupin. That's how it reads to me, and that's why I see him as gay.
Thanks for the reply. That’s what I was asking for, the point of view of others. I’m all for personal interpretation and that’s the main reason why I don’t see Jigen as gay simply because I can’t see him being attracted to Lupin. Probably it has to do with projection on my part because I personally don’t find Lupin attractive at all.

Since Lupin was from the beginning a very problematic character and even if they basically rewrote him for the anime, to me he still maintains his original traits that are being incredibly self centered and having an ego the size of Jupiter.

Therefore in my personal interpretation I see them exactly as the other way around, meaning I can see Lupin being attracted to Jigen. In Zero, Lupin claiming to have stolen Jigen’s heart is just typical Lupin being so arrogant to believe that everyone is in love with him, when it’s him who falls in love and takes what he likes.
He does the same when he claims that Fujiko is his girlfriend, without Fujiko’s consent, in part 1. Also, a 13yo kid who goes after a woman, Yoko, twice his age… let’s just say that Lupin kind of imposes himself on others.

In every verse of Lupin and Jigen meeting it’s always Lupin who goes after Jigen not the other way around. On the contrary Jigen can’t be bothered less.

I know I sound like a broken record, but imo you can’t ignore the origins of the characters and fully understand them: in the manga Lupin is a sort of a rapist when it comes to women, Jigen (and Goemon too) don’t approve of the way Lupin treats women. How that manages to translate into Jigen being jealous in the anime is beyond me.

Having said that I find some redeeming traits in Lupin and they are his loyalty and him actually caring about his friends, especially Jigen to whom he seems to have a special bond.

I hope I have made myself clear this time, it wasn’t my intention to start a polemic, I just wanted to understand how the different dynamics among the characters are perceived.

Sorry, editing to add:
if Lupin and Jigen in Zero were a boy and a girl in that exact situation
but they’re not and while I see your point I’d say that you’re forcing Jigen into the heteronormative position of the “girl”.

And no, personally I would still see Lupin as a total arrogant ass even if Jigen were a girl.

I know Lupin is the main character and all the others are supposed to only exist in relation to him but forcing Fujiko, just because she’s female into the role of the girlfriend or forcing Jigen just because he’s male into the role of the gay lover is kind of repeating the same normative structure.
 
Last edited:

lupingavemebrainrot

Hurr de Durr I have lupin brain rot
Pronouns
She/Her
the manga makes things like character sexualities so easy to know off the bat like in the manga:

1. jigen-in the closet gay man who probably only tops and fucks his boss rarely.
2. lupin-opportunistic sex pest pretty much bi but rape isn't really about sex its about power, so even in actions like rape by deception ex: the time lupin literally tricked the authors self insert into boinking him in female disguise, or doing to same zenigata, these actions can not prove sexuality because lupin is a rapist. I say bi tentatively because lupin is a big rapist in the manga.
fujiko-findom, possibly asexual.
goemon-asexual, the samurai need no worldy things like sex.
zenigata-as straight as he is as authoritarian right.
 
Last edited:
I do feel suspicious that you didn't even introduce yourself or have any other discussion in the forum, you instead came to a thread about gay subtext to call queer people delusional. Consider this a firm warning about your behavior. You are welcome to talk about your own interpretations, but not to insult other people who interpret the work differently than you.
As someone who loves me a queer Jigen as much as anyone (i'm the Jigen's Giant Purple Dildo Esteban person) I find it, pardon my french, really fucking weird to threaten to ban someone for pointing out that it's not really canon.

Yes, I've seen Zero. I've also seen Cagliostro, which Zero riffs heavily on, and the heart theft Lupin did in Cagliostro was explicitly not romantic or god forbid sexual. I love the gay interpretation of the heart theft A LOT, but to insist that it's the only valid and god forbid canonical interpretation is just baffling to me; for example, I'm aroace and have aroace friends who love that scene because it doesn't have to be interpreted as strictly romantic.

It doesn't have to be canon to be FUN. And it is fun, and there's a lot of eyebrow raising shit in Lupin media. I just don't see it as the canonically defensible position.

Not trying to stir shit, I just think "Jigen isn't canonically gay" isn't a controversial statement.
 

Tsushi

Matcha-Coated Tanuki Mod
Admin
Pronouns
He/They
Sorry, editing to add:

but they’re not and while I see your point I’d say that you’re forcing Jigen into the heteronormative position of the “girl”.

And no, personally I would still see Lupin as a total arrogant ass even if Jigen were a girl.
First off I didn't say Jigen was the girl, I said if they were a girl and a boy this scene would be seen easily as romantic. The same statement I made is true if Lupin were a girl and Jigen were a boy. To say that because they are both boys it must be friendship and not romance is what is heteronormative. Two boys can be in love just as much as any heterosexual couple.

And I can totally understand if you don't like Lupin. I agree and I think he IS an arrogant asshole. An egomaniac who thinks of himself and his vanity first.

I think that is a stumbling block in he and Fujiko's relationship, and I think Jigen in many cases lets himself be treated poorly by Lupin in ways Fujiko won't tolerate, because Jigen has lower self worth. He constantly has an urge to sacrifice himself for others.

I think of that as one of Jigen's flaws, that he gives a pass to Lupin's bad behavior and loves him anyway, even when he behaves badly. Episode 0 in Part 6 Fujiko says to Jigen that Jigen is the only one who can tolerate Lupin long term. And I think that's true.

I find it very interesting how Jigen would look past Lupin's faults, even if they're large faults. He is a very flawed character, but just like in life, flawed people are loved and fall in love.

I see them as teaching each other things that make them into better people. That Lupin persues Jigen because he is fascinated by him, and that Lupin teaches Jigen, who is a very dour person, how to have fun again. He awakens that joy in Jigen and makes him smile. And Jigen teaches Lupin to be more gentle and grounded, he helps Lupin have an anchor. Also in Part 6 Episode 0 he says Jigen being so steady and unchanging has helped him feel strong enough to evolve and be the person he wants to be.
 

lupingavemebrainrot

Hurr de Durr I have lupin brain rot
Pronouns
She/Her
if jigen is not gay in lupin 0, then at the very least it would be romantic friendship, yes you can have friendships so intense it borders on romance. I mean alot of people over look the changing gender roles during the creation of lupin, that sort thing of displaced men so media geared toward men romanticized manly man shit to the point it feels almost gay for awhile, at least to me, male power fantasies feel kind of gay to me, jigen's and lupins intense bromance could very well be a hang over of that era.
 
First off I didn't say Jigen was the girl, I said if they were a girl and a boy this scene would be seen easily as romantic. The same statement I made is true if Lupin were a girl and Jigen were a boy. To say that because they are both boys it must be friendship and not romance is what is heteronormative. Two boys can be in love just as much as any heterosexual couple.
Not by me, if they were a boy and a girl that scene of one of them showing off a ginormous ego while claiming in front of others that the other person is in love with them would still be the showing off of a megalomaniac.
Of course two boys, or two girls, can be in love. But is it really the case here?

I think we can agree that Lupin and Fujiko is NOT the love story of the century but the point is that Fujiko is her own character as much as Jigen is. Frankly I don’t see him being submissive with Lupin, he gives back as much as he receives and when he doesn’t it’s because it’s his job to protect others, not only Lupin. Being loyal and protective isn’t something that has to do with sexuality now, or is it? Jigen’s job, or even role as a character, is to save Lupin’s crazy ass since without Jigen Lupin would have been dead by episode 2.

Really, I’m the biggest supporter of Lupin and Jigen together, I’m super happy this show gives a lot of importance to Lupin and Jigen even more importance than that given to the traditional hetero couple, and I am not trying to convince anyone about anything. I repeat mine was just a curiosity about what makes people decide of a fictional character’s sexuality.

If I may say my take on them is that they ALL live a solitary life, by choice obviously, because a life on the run doesn’t sit well with settling down. Oddly enough Jigen seems the only one to actually look for an alternative life, both in terms of changing line of work and of having affairs with women who are outside of his line of work.

Let’s hope he doesn’t find one as I don’t want a show without Jigen nor the show to turn into a sit com.
 

Tsushi

Matcha-Coated Tanuki Mod
Admin
Pronouns
He/They
As someone who loves me a queer Jigen as much as anyone (i'm the Jigen's Giant Purple Dildo Esteban person) I find it, pardon my french, really fucking weird to threaten to ban someone for pointing out that it's not really canon.

It wasn't the pointing out it's not "canon" that made me feel the need to issue a warning. It was how it was said and where it was said.

This board is called Headcanons, not canons, it's not like "Jigen is straight in canon" was a necessary thing to say here.

It was suspicious to me to see someone have only one post and have it be here and have this tone. What reason is there to come into the queer Jigen thread, to put a winky emoji implying that if people with a queer interpretation of Jigen were were really fans "all it would take is a few minutes to do a little research"?

What concerned me was coming directly into a space of people talking about their queer interpretations and being rude and not having interacted positively anywhere else.

I don't see that as automatically ban worthy, but I see it as a concern. Hopefully my explanation makes sense. I think it's fine to have a discussion, as long as it is had in good faith but I am very wary of this kind of framing, and calling queer people delusional etc.

This is something comforting and fun for people, just like the aro/ace interpretation you're talking about, I am glad that exists for them. I wouldn't want people calling them delusional for seeing it that way either. Insulting people's headcanons about queerness is a common silencing tactic so I take it very seriously. As a queer person just trying to enjoy things, people will insert themselves into your conversation and call you weird or perverted or delusional.

I promise that I try to be fair and give people a chance to explain themselves. I'm sorry if it seemed aggro, I don't mean to, I intended to sound stern, but I apologize if it came off as threatening.
 
I apologise, again, for entering the discussion but if I want to hear people’s opinions specifically on Jigen’s alleged sexuality where am I supposed to post if not in the thread about Jigen’s alleged sexuality?

The other thing the sits wrong with me about the heart stealing scene in Zero is that it could have happened in private, Lupin could have told Jigen about his feelings in their secret hideout. Instead they chose to set the whole scene in a theatrical way in front of Lupin’s father/Shinobou, which automatically turns the whole thing into a challenge between father and son and leaves Jigen with no escape but accept and laugh about it. Again, that’s typical Lupin showing off completely disregarding other people’s feelings.
I would argue that that’s not how love works, making Jigen into his trophy just to rub his father’s face in. And Jigen is not stupid, I don’t think he took that seriously for a second.

I criticise the whole thing and at the same time I love the food for tought this show never fails to deliver.
 
What concerned me was coming directly into a space of people talking about their queer interpretations and being rude and not having interacted positively anywhere else.
Everyone has to start somewhere! And for what it's worth, I don't think they were rude? They disagreed but I didn't see anything rude in their first post, or really any post after that. You seem to have latched onto the word "delusional" which they did use fleetingly, but I don't think they used it incorrectly or insultingly? It CAN be seen as delusional to insist stuff is canon that isn't. Probably not the best turn of phrase but it is what it is.
This is something comforting and fun for people, just like the aro/ace interpretation you're talking about, I am glad that exists for them. I wouldn't want people calling them delusional for seeing it that way either. Insulting people's headcanons about queerness is a common silencing tactic so I take it very seriously. As a queer person just trying to enjoy things, people will insert themselves into your conversation and call you weird or perverted or delusional.
Just so you know, this comes off as extremely condescending. I'm queer too. I've dabbled in fandoms just as long, if not longer, than you. I certainly don't need to be told that this is comforting and fun for people. I didn't see them insulting anyone's headcanons, just maybe critiquing their perceptions of canon. Which isn't something to take personally?

Again, this is coming from someone who just finished writing a (banger) post lupin zero fic so like, I get entirely where you're coming from and I understand your point of view, I just don't think Mine did or is doing anything so out of line as to warrant this kind of honestly pretty paranoid, hackles-up response.

Anyway, i'm derailing hardcore. I just was utterly astounded that Jigen "slander" was apparently a nigh-bannable offense.
 

Tsushi

Matcha-Coated Tanuki Mod
Admin
Pronouns
He/They
Just so you know, this comes off as extremely condescending. I'm queer too. I've dabbled in fandoms just as long, if not longer, than you. I certainly don't need to be told that this is comforting and fun for people. I didn't see them insulting anyone's headcanons, just maybe critiquing their perceptions of canon. Which isn't something to take personally?
Sorry about that, I tend to lean towards over explaining when I feel like I might be misunderstood, I didn't mean to insult you.

I tried my best to explain why I took it very seriously. Earlier in this thread there were people who said they saw Jigen as having feelings for women, or that the writers have written him as straight, him being straight or being bi, and it wasn't any kind of issue prior. It wasn't about Jigen slander, it was honestly about feeling protective of people feeling safe talking about queerness without being insulted.

It's perfectly fine to be curious about why others would see Jigen as queer, I would think that would be what might make reading this thread helpful. I just felt it was a possible red flag considering all the factors. I'm sorry if I hurt anyone, I just am cautious, considering how hostile some places online can be about queer fandom stuff. I probably am paranoid, the hostility online lately towards queer people has been getting to me I think. My apologies.
 

lupingavemebrainrot

Hurr de Durr I have lupin brain rot
Pronouns
She/Her
my only question is:
are we ever going to debate whether or not lupin can be yandere? because I like yandere men in fiction. I love me a good yandere. I think part 7 lupin had the most yandere potential, given the mind fuckery his fake mom did, and him rule breaking and killing said fake mom.
 
Pronouns
She/they
I do not believe that there's been a systematic effort over the years from the creators to portray Jigen as being into men. Do I care? Not one bit; my heart says he's into men (and women, but more into men, and his relationships with them are different). For me, fandom is all about fanworks and ideas and having fun, and it's completely irrelevant to me what happened in canon or what the creators meant. That's why I usually stay out of this kind of discussions because while I understand that other people enjoy compiling evidence to support their headcanons, I end up feeling defensive, like I'm not allowed to view a character in a certain way unless I can pull up screenshots and dialogue that support my view.
 
Last edited:
I never said people shouldn’t have a personal headcanon. Once again, I just wanted to know how people is so sure about interpretations as they were written in stone when those are, instead, not in canon.

I understand wanting to see yourself in your favourite character. In the end it all comes down to:
  • I like Jigen because he is gay, or rather
  • I like Jigen therefore I want him to be gay
To be clear, I use the ‘gay’ label only because he’s mainly seen as in love with Lupin.
Well I can assure you that, since I identify as ace, that doesn’t stop me from liking the character even if he isn’t ace. He can be ace in my personal headcanon all I want but I wouldn’t expect from the authors to give me canonically ace Jigen. Nor I go nitpicking the media for evidence of him being ace.

In reality no one will ever be satisfied with the character’s sexuality because he can’t be gay, bi, straight, ace, whatever at the same time.

I don’t think characters, or people for that matter, should be reduced to a sexuality label especially when they’re complex enough you can find plenty of reasons to like them anyway. Jigen has a specific role in the Lupin narrative, which is that of the positive foil to Lupin’s craziness. For example I always saw Lupin as the aggressive (rapist) guy and Jigen as the non aggressive (non rapist) guy. Well excuse me if that alone puts me firmly on Jigen’s side.

I believe the reason we all are here is that we have a fascination with two characters that are by canon straight but at the same time share a canonical special bond that borders, for western viewers in particular, on the romantic (you have to concede it to the authors that they never shied away from that). At least it was before people started wanting to put a label at all costs on their relationship and on Jigen in particular.

Official canon has never stopped personal headcanons from being valid. Definitely enjoy your favourite characters the way you want them to be. It’s the presumption that our personal headcanon should be the official canon that is, imo, wrong.
 
Pronouns
She/they
I think we're more or less in agreement. I was just expressing my frustrations with kind of discussions in general because they so often lead to hurt feelings. Lupin fandom is super chill, but in other fandoms I've seen things get really hostile if someone expresses disagreement with the interpretations that people take for granted.
 

lupingavemebrainrot

Hurr de Durr I have lupin brain rot
Pronouns
She/Her
I do not believe that there's been a systematic effort over the years from the creators to potray Jigen as being into men. Do I care? Not one bit; my heart says he's into men (and women, but more into men, and his relationships with them are different). For me, fandom is all about fanworks and ideas and having fun, and it's completely irrelevant to me what happened in canon or what the creators meant. That's why I usually stay out of this kind of discussions because while I understand that other people enjoy compiling evidence to support their headcanons, I end up feeling defensive, like I'm not allowed to view a character in a certain way unless I can pull up screenshots and dialogue that support my view.
I feel ya personal lupin head canon and ai bot behaves like this:
my idea of lupin is basicall manga jokereque minus all the sa in the manga. idk why I just find it interesting I love me a good anti hero.
 
Top